The Doctors taste wine-inspired waters. These waters promise to offer all of the antioxidants of wine without the alcoholic buzz. Plastic surgeon Dr. Andrew Ordon comments that they look like rosé. But as for the taste? Not so much.

Watch: Can Drinking Wine Help You Lose Weight?

ER physician Dr. Travis Stork says he’s not into it! He says they don’t taste like wine at all. It’s closer to really sweet water. Dr. Ordon agrees that it’s too sweet. However, he says for someone who wants to partake in a celebration but not consume alcohol, maybe it’s an option.

OB/GYN Dr. Nita Landry tastes the artificial sweetener and agrees, no wine-taste here! 

Watch: Water vs. Sparkling Water - What Should You Choose?

Want a Doctor's approved wine-swap? Try this drink in the video below!