The Triplets Put Ancestry Kits to the Test

This video is unavailable because we were unable to load a message from our sponsors.

If you are using ad-blocking software, please disable it and reload the page.
Playing Different DNA Results for Triplets Using At-Home Tests?

Identical triplets Nicole, Erica, and Jaclyn are frequent guests of The Doctors – but what will DNA testing reveal about their relationship to each other? "Inside Edition" investigative journalist Lisa Guerrero wants to find out.

Erica is married to The Doctors executive producer Jay McGraw, and she, Jaclyn, and Nicole have shared their pregnancy and motherhood journeys with The Doctors audience. Now they're going to make a contribution to science on-camera!

Watch: Catching Up with the Triplets

At-home DNA tests have become so popular that just one of the companies offering them has 3 million customers. But how accurate are the tests? Identical twins and triplets are the perfect subjects for DNA testing because their genes should be exactly the same.

Inside Edition has asked the triplets to take two different tests. One is to determine whether the triplets are identical. Are they SURE? Erica says that she's positive – she can even open the safe at Nicole's house because their fingerprints are exactly the same.

Watch: The Docs' Favorite Triplets

Sure enough, the test correctly showed that the triplets are identical! “You could believe your eyes,” Lisa laughs.

But the second test is supposed to reveal ancestry. Where in the world do the triplets' origins lie? And here there are some surprising results.

Although all three triplets have 99 percent European ancestry, the specific results for areas of Europe disagree among the sisters by as much as 10 percent. Some of them show more English and Irish ancestry, another more French and German.

“It's shocking!” one triplet says.

Watch: Jillian's DNA Test

ER Physician Dr. Travis Stork says the at-home tests are great for fun. “Everyone is a little curious about where they come from.”

Lisa points out that testing the triplets tells us something about how accurate the tests really are – their results should have been identical. But she still plans to try an in-home kit herself, and also to spend a little more to get a more accurate test from a doctor.

Dr. Stork observes that while genetic testing has made a lot of progress, “We're not to a place yet where you can just spit in a cup and have every single answer that you're looking for.”